Talk:Asteroid

Photo journal

Perhaps stating the obvious, but a project for someone could be a time-lapse series or photo journal of the Beta development of a Early Access map. Might not come to anything, but you don't know if you will capture something interesting unless you start shooting before changes. Don't want a large gallery, but I was wondering if a slide show viewer interface is available to present several temporally, spatially, or topically related images in a single box. Mikado282 (talk) 06:24, 9 July 2014 (PDT)

That would be nice, but I don't know if there is a way to put in a slideshow on this wiki. Perhaps another page, hidden from search results but linked to in the Release Changes? Professor Harpo (talk) 08:16, 19 July 2014 (PDT)

Reactor Cores and "daytime"

First, how can anyone say it's midday when it's in the middle of space? I'll remove that from the "Setting", and the "Reactor cores" shown in the pictures aren't what they're said to be. Those are just the "points" (I sometimes call them batteries) that upon collection, give the score to your team. The Reactor Cores are the big devices behind the laser traps.

I just wanted to point that out, even if I'm captain obvious. Dafuq? (talk) 09:43, 9 July 2014 (PDT)

This coincided with someone else asking for better images on the IRC which I've just uploaded, but thanks for bringing up the point about the Reactor Cores. The cores shown in original pictures are actually Power Cores, going off of the model names. Thanks for fixing the Setting bit as well! --Omolong (talk) 10:37, 9 July 2014 (PDT)

"Maps supporting bots"

How am I not able to remove this category from the page? I don't see the categories anywhere for editing. I ran nav_generate on this map and added player bots, but they just stayed in their spawn and didn't go anywhere. For the moment, it seems that the Robot Destruction mode does not support bots. Dogman15 (talk) 11:38, 9 July 2014 (PDT)

For the record, the map already comes with a navmesh. Don't generate your own one.--Henke37 (talk) 10:58, 11 July 2014 (PDT)

This is a beta map, so the likelihood of it supporting bots is slim to none, seeing as Valve has yet to add bot support to the Arena mode entirely, and has not corrected bot behavior in a while (see Bots#Bugs) Professor Harpo (talk) 08:16, 19 July 2014 (PDT)

Robot Audio Responses

Since this is a beta map, the voice lines may be altered, added, or changed for the robots. Also, since there is no official name for the robots and the number of lines are so few, I don't believe that it warrants a separate voice responses page. I was thinking to just add the lines to this page of the Robot Destruction page.

Here are the transcripts as follows:

Note: These voice lines are in beta and may be altered in the future. In addition, robots occasionally emit the death-notice sound from Half-Life

Idle

"Beep boop." "Beep boop beep."

When an enemy crosses circuit path

"Path not found." "Er-ror." "Error."

Under attack

"Oww." "Ow."

Death

"Oh no." [gurgling noise]

Move/Merge Robots?

rd_ Robots are presently described in two places, Asteroid and Robot Destruction; both descriptions have valid but different information. The Robot section is natural in the Asteroid article, because it describes an important part of the play on that map. However, it must be presumed that the rd_ Robots as featured in Asteroid are the fundamental mechanism of the Robot Destruction game mode, which presents a problem when the second rd_ map comes out (like the second sd_ map). So, moved/merge to Robot Destruction? Leave? Will rd_ Robots have the same behavior on every rd_ map? Speculation? They probably don't get their own Robots (Robot Destruction) article like MvM Robots, because they are so simple and so integral to the game mode map operation and scoring. Mikado282 (talk) 23:04, 10 July 2014 (PDT)

I'd treat it exactly like how Control Point info is treated on the Wiki. Map pages like Dustbowl list gameplay-related information, like a table with capture time information, and pictures of the point placements, but not much else. Gameplay objective pages like Control Point (objective) go further in-depth on what the heck they are and what function they serve in the game. So "Control Point (obj)" = "Robots (RD)", and "Dustbowl" = "Asteroid".

There's also another thing: the Reactor Core that can be stolen like an Intel briefcase. Where does that end up moving? I think it should stay in the Robot Destruction hub page, but I'm not sure. Pakaku (talk) 16:38, 14 July 2014 (PDT)

IMO, going by the (reasonable?) assumption that Reactor Core mechanics are integral to Robot Destruction gamemode, Reactor Core mechanics (examples: weapon effects, effects on carrier, how to charge) should go under Robot Destruction#Reactor Cores and details of how they work with scoring (example: charging instantaneously changes score) should go under Robot Destruction#Scoring. I realise that in the future we may see that things like number of robots, damage points, or Power Core counts may vary between RD maps. It is a more complicated game mode; so I think it deserves more structure in the articles. Mikado282 (talk) 11:50, 16 July 2014 (PDT)

The problem with all of this is that a) this is a beta gamemode, so changes are constant, and b) we simply don't know which components from Asteroid will make it to other rd_ maps, or if there are going to be other rd_ maps. I would stay on the safe side and keep the link in Robot Destruction#Robots that points to Asteroid#Robots, at least until other rd_ maps come out or Asteroid comes out of beta. Professor Harpo (talk) 08:16, 19 July 2014 (PDT)