Talk:Community Engineer strategy

Sentry Placement

This section needs revision. Possibly there needs to be a new section on how to place Sentries using the Wrangler, as many of this information currently assumes using the vanilla Sentry.

I would suggest a whole new page called "Sentry placement" be created that contains a graphical guide to placing Sentries on the various maps, instead of relying on vague written descriptions, as well as different sections covering vanilla Sentries, mini-Sentries, and Wrangler Sentries. This would be a large undertaking, so if anyone else is interested in creating this, please comment here. --Aranarth 17:00, 10 July 2010 (UTC)

I added a couple of diagrams that I made to illustrate graphically some of the things I added to the Sentry Placement General strategies section which I reorganized somewhat. --Aranarth 05:15, 1 August 2010 (UTC)

• Just for future reference avoid using bold italics -- the map specific section here was full of bold italic words which should be avoided. Plain italics or all CAPS is better for emphasis, bold font is generally used to denote sections within an article. The Wiki style guide explains this. --Aranarth 16:56, 1 August 2010 (UTC)

Thanks to Aranarth this section has really :) filled out. I'm reading through and initially doing some minor edits for consistency and such...which is what I typically do from time to time when I add some new content from an update or something I've figured out myself. I see that Hackett is heading up a global project, so I'll see what I can do and coordinate in Talk:Strategy. The diagrams do work well for general placement strategy, but I think in-game screenshots will be the only way to go for map specific placements. But, with screenshots even limited to 320x200 pixels this page will become too heavy. We should consider breaking out map specific placements into seperate pages.Rockn-Roll 07:52, 22 August 2010 (UTC)

Weapon Specific

Try to avoid adding tips here that are redundant. Please make sure you read through the section already to make sure you don't add information that's already been mentioned. I would say that most of the significant strategy for the items has been mentioned, there's not need to "scrape the bottom of the barrel" for more possibilities, if you can see what I mean. The purpose of this section is not to list all possible strategies for a weapon, but to 1) help new players understand what these items can do quickly and 2) mention some possibilities that may not occur to most people but are definitely useful.

An example of what not to do: someone recently posted a tip telling people to "Spy check" with the Gunslinger, and that its 3 hit combo can kill Spies. First, that is not technically "Spy Checking" it's just "Spy killing" but more importantly most if not all players will do this without needing to be told that it's a "strategy" for this item. Punching enemies or suspected enemies with this item is obvious and is similar to saying "a good strategy for the shotgun is to shoot it at enemies." --Aranarth 17:26, 11 July 2010 (UTC)

Someone recently added to the weapon combination table and I changed the description to emphasize how weak the Gunslinger/Wrangler/Justice loadout is. The weapon combination table is not to simply list all possible combinations, but to list recommended combos and outline their strategic role on a team. Using all 3 unlockables together is contradictory, as 2 of them were designed to support Sentry-dependent play that emphasizes holding down positions, whereas the Gunslinger was designed for a completely different, mobile playstyle that emphasizes attacking and de-emphasizes the Sentry Gun and base-building in general. Using all 3 of them together makes no sense and will only "work" against completely inexperienced players. I left it there simply to discourage anyone from using this combo. If you disagree, discuss it here, but I strongly feel from experience that my advice is sound. Its comparable to using the Direct Hit with the Buff Banner or using the Eyelander without the Targe (with no Heads), or advising Snipers to use the Huntsman from the longest possible range. These strats just aren't as good. --Aranarth 17:53, 22 August 2010 (UTC)

Toolbox Kill Icon

I think it would be useful find a place where to explain what means the Toolbox kill icon you see when an engie is killed while hauling a building. I think here is the best page. Ideas? --Kid Of The Century 13:18, 12 July 2010 (UTC)

Sure. Actually I think we should reorganize the page to include a small section on "hauling", explaining the mechanic and how to use it, since there are currently tips and notes involving it all over the strategy page it might be better to concentrate them. We could include the information on the toolbox kill icon there too. --Aranarth 21:45, 12 July 2010 (UTC)

Hauling already exists Here, feel free to add to it, the toolbox kill icon is there as well, perhaps there could simply be links to it. --Firestorm 21:49, 12 July 2010 (UTC)

Added a fun strategy of Mini-Sentry + Pistol DPS.--Ikimono1 03:15, 13 July 2010 (UTC)