Difference between revisions of "Team Fortress Wiki:Debrief"
(Created page with '== Podcast articles == What happened today with Control Point podcast, User:Brentcopeland and User:JohnnyNapalm? # On 18 September, Control Point podcast was ta…') |
m |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | {{historical}} | ||
== Podcast articles == | == Podcast articles == | ||
What happened today with [[Control Point podcast]], [[User:Brentcopeland|Brentcopeland]] and [[User:JohnnyNapalm|JohnnyNapalm]]? | What happened today with [[Control Point podcast]], [[User:Brentcopeland|Brentcopeland]] and [[User:JohnnyNapalm|JohnnyNapalm]]? | ||
| Line 4: | Line 5: | ||
# On 20 October, the page was drastically summarized by [[User:Zoolooman|Zoolooman]] under the guidance of many in the [[Project:IRC|IRC]] channel to address the issue. | # On 20 October, the page was drastically summarized by [[User:Zoolooman|Zoolooman]] under the guidance of many in the [[Project:IRC|IRC]] channel to address the issue. | ||
# Between 22 to 24 October, the article was reverted between these revisions six times by various editors. | # Between 22 to 24 October, the article was reverted between these revisions six times by various editors. | ||
| − | # The issue was discussed on [[Talk:KritzKast Podcast|KritzKast's talk page]]. | + | # The issue was discussed on [[Talk:KritzKast Podcast/Archive 1|KritzKast's talk page]]. |
##During some of the discussion, JohnnyNapalm removed content he personally deemed irrelevant. Whether it was or not is not up to the average user to decide. | ##During some of the discussion, JohnnyNapalm removed content he personally deemed irrelevant. Whether it was or not is not up to the average user to decide. | ||
##This issue was brought up with him on his [[User_talk:JohnnyNapalm|talk page]]. It was met with irreverence and maintained we were "colossal hypocrites". He was subsequently banned. | ##This issue was brought up with him on his [[User_talk:JohnnyNapalm|talk page]]. It was met with irreverence and maintained we were "colossal hypocrites". He was subsequently banned. | ||
# On 28 October, content on [[Control Point podcast]] was blanked by [[User:Brentcopeland|Brentcopeland]] citing editorial censorship, copyright issues and claiming the wiki was a "piece of shit". | # On 28 October, content on [[Control Point podcast]] was blanked by [[User:Brentcopeland|Brentcopeland]] citing editorial censorship, copyright issues and claiming the wiki was a "piece of shit". | ||
| − | # | + | # [[User:Brentcopeland|Brentcopeland]] was banned due to a confrontational attitude. Remaining related content was then deleted by [[User:Pilk|Pilk]]. |
Latest revision as of 15:03, 10 October 2011
 | This project page is no longer active, and is kept for historical record only. |
Podcast articles
What happened today with Control Point podcast, Brentcopeland and JohnnyNapalm?
- On 18 September, Control Point podcast was tagged with
{{advertisement}}by Pilk. Though not an official policy statement, articles should remain neutral and not exaggerate or overestimate their subject. - On 20 October, the page was drastically summarized by Zoolooman under the guidance of many in the IRC channel to address the issue.
- Between 22 to 24 October, the article was reverted between these revisions six times by various editors.
- The issue was discussed on KritzKast's talk page.
- During some of the discussion, JohnnyNapalm removed content he personally deemed irrelevant. Whether it was or not is not up to the average user to decide.
- This issue was brought up with him on his talk page. It was met with irreverence and maintained we were "colossal hypocrites". He was subsequently banned.
- On 28 October, content on Control Point podcast was blanked by Brentcopeland citing editorial censorship, copyright issues and claiming the wiki was a "piece of shit".
- Brentcopeland was banned due to a confrontational attitude. Remaining related content was then deleted by Pilk.
