Team Fortress Wiki:Community topics notability assessment project/Custom map assessments
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
This page serves as a comprehensive reference for assessing the notability of Custom maps on the Team Fortress Wiki. Please read the full guidelines for more detailed information.
Glossary:
- Patched / Added : Content added to the game by Valve through updates.
- Official : Maps developed by Valve and officially added through updates.
- Community : Maps created by the community and added via official updates that were not developed by Valve.
- Custom : Maps created by the community but not yet officially added to the game by Valve.
Notability criteria:
- Notability basis:
For and 
Against notability. - Assessment: The outcome of the assessment with a link to the discussion as needed.
Assessments
| List of Custom Map Notability Assessments | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Custom map | Notability basis | Assessment | Notes / Context | |
| Custom maps with later variants that were added by Valve: | ||||
| Ambush (custom map) Bagel Brine Coal Fifthcurve Firewatch Maple Ridge Millstone Moonshine Nocturne Rumble Rumford (custom map) Slaughter Sludgepit Stoneyridge Synthetic Undergrove Vineyard |
Has added variant
|
Having an added variant alone is sufficient notability. | ||
| Custom maps with no known notability (recently created pages, typically 2020-2021). | ||||
| Conifer Free2fort Gibson Hybrid Npire Strata Zinkenite Valley |
No notability
|
Recently created pages with no known notability. | ||
| Custom maps with no stated notability (pages typically created around 2014-2015): | ||||
| Alpen Mesaworks Final Destination 2015 Wubwubwub |
 Unknown notability
|
2014-2015 postings with no stated notability. Generally posted and/or maintained by only one editor, Dr. Scaphandre, but other ranking editors are also recorded as making edits to these pages (e.g., TidB, Tark, Darkid ). | ||
| "Ancient" custom map pages with no stated notability (except possibly they may be competitive): | ||||
| Antiquity 2011 Cashworks Convoy 2010 Cranetop Dusk Furnace Creek Hunted (custom map) Meridian Stoneyridge |
Cashworks Convoy No evidence of notability for the rest
|
| ||
| Historic custom maps with many variants that were widely popular on Community servers or introduced features to the game or Community server activities: | ||||
| Achievement Idle Glacier (1st snowfall) (mentioned in Blog) Orange X Trainsawlaser Morrigan Alley Trade Plaza Minecraft Walkway |
Historic
|
|||
| Custom maps used for Competitive games: | ||||
| Obscure Product (competitive Viaduct) Warmfront (competitive Coldfront) |
Competitive
|
|||
| Custom maps that have Competitive variants: | ||||
| Coalplant |
Has competitive variant
|
|||
| Custom maps made to demonstrate Community content packs: | ||||
| Backlot | Content pack
|
Swamp Theme | ||
| Atrophy Hardhat |
Content pack
|
Construction Theme | ||
| Mapping contest winners: | ||||
| Nightfall (1st) (added) Panic · Solitude Highwind (4th) · Cornfield · Scoville · Arctic · Animus · Rollout · Rollout · Vector · Slate · Premuda · Snowdrift · Panamint · Bayou |
Contest winners
|
A/D CTF and Payload Race Contest 2009 | ||
| Wildfire (1st) Fusion (3rd) Stockpile (7th) Landfall (9th) (Added) Overlook (10th) |
Contest winners
|
Competitive CTF Contest 2010 | ||
| Croissant (1st) Process (2nd) (Added) |
Contest winners
|
(A)Symmetry CP Contest 2011 (only 1st and 2nd place covered) | ||
| Custom maps from Potato MvM mapping competitions and events: | ||||
| Teien Airdrop Sequoia Steep |
Contest winners
|
Mappers vs Machines Contest 2017 | ||
| Dockyard Waterfront Downtown Steep Teien Powerplant Metro |
Community events Contest winners
|
Operation Titanium Tank 2017 Reforged 2020 | ||
| Area 52 · Barren · Calico · Casino City · Coastrock · Condemned · Dockyard · Doppler · Downtown · Giza · Hideout · Isolation · Metro · Outlands · Oxidize · Powerplant · Quetzal · Radar · Sequoia · Shiverpeak · Skullcove · Snowpine · Spacepost · Steep · Teien · Trainyard · Underground · Waterfront · Waterlogged · Yucatan | Community events Contest winners
|
Operation Canteen Crasher 2018-2019 Was there in fact a vetting mapping competition? | ||
| Area 52 · Barren · Brugge · Casino City · Coastrock · Cyberia · Derelict · Dockyard · Doppler · Downpour · Frostwynd · Goldpit · Hanami · Hillside · Hideout · Hoovy Dam · Isolation · Kelly · Maple Hill · Meltdown · Metro · Oilrig · Outlands · Oxidize · Powerplant · Production · Quetzal · Radar · Redstone Ridge · Rust Valley · Sequoia · Shiverpeak · Silent Sky · Skullcove · Snowpine · Spacepost · Steep · Teien · Transmission · Trainyard · Underground · Waterfront · Waterlogged · Winterbridge · Wizardry | Community events Contest winners
|
Operation Madness vs Machines 2019-2020 Was there in fact a vetting mapping competition? | ||
| Akure · Autumnull · Boogge · Cliffside · Dusk · Estate · Giza · Goldpit · Hanami · Hideout · Hoovy Dam · Kelly · Production · Rust Valley · Seabed · Sharp · Silent Sky · Swirl · Tensai · Transmission · Winterbridge · Yiresa | Community events Contest winners
|
Operation Digital Directive 2019-2020 Was there in fact a vetting mapping competition? | ||
- 62 = Total MvM maps in larger Potato Events
- 18 = Covered
- 44 = Not covered
| Measurement of Potato MvM Map Coverage | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| |||
